# A guide to the GEMINI R package

#### Mahdi Zamanighomi and Sidharth Jain

#### 2022-04-26

## Abstract

Systems for CRISPR-based combinatorial perturbation of two or more genes are emerging as powerful tools for uncovering genetic interactions. However, systematic identification of these relationships is complicated by sample, reagent, and biological variability. We develop a variational Bayes approach (GEMINI) that jointly analyzes all samples and reagents to identify genetic interactions in pairwise knockout screens. The improved accuracy and scalability of GEMINI enables the systematic analysis of combinatorial CRISPR knockout screens, regardless of design and dimension.

### Introduction

GEMINI follows a basic workflow:

- Create Input (`gemini_create_input`)
- Initialize Model (`gemini_initialize`)
- Perform Coordinate-Ascent Variational Inference (CAVI) (`gemini_inference`)
- Score Interactions (`gemini_score`)

Using counts data derived from a combination CRISPR screen, and annotations for both samples/replicates and guide/gene IDs, GEMINI can identify genetic interactions such as synthetic lethality and recovery.

### Model

GEMINI uses the following model:

\(D_{gihjl} = N(x_{gi} * y_{gl} + x_{hj}*x_{hl} + x_{gihj}*s_{ghl}, \tau_{gihjl})\)

- \(D\) is the observation, the log-fold change of a guide pair in a cell line.

- \(x\) is the reagent-level effect, reflecting the consistency of a single guide or guide pair across samples

- \(y\) is the gene-level effect, reflecting the effect of gene knockout in a single sample.

- \(s\) is the combination effect, reflecting the effect of the interaction between a gene pair

- \(\tau\) is the precision of the data

- \(g\) is a gene targeted by guide \(i\)

- \(h\) is a gene targeted by guide \(j\)

- \(l\) is the sample

### Installation

The stable version used in the publication Zamanighomi et al., 2019 can be found on Bioconductor:

    if (!requireNamespace("BiocManager", quietly = TRUE))
        install.packages("BiocManager")

    BiocManager::install("gemini")

For the latest development version, you can download from GitHub using the devtools package:

    if (!requireNamespace("devtools", quietly = TRUE))
        install.packages("devtools")

    devtools::install_github("foo/bar", build_opts = c("--no-resave-data", "--no-manual"), build_vignettes = TRUE)

### Import Big Papi data

This is the data published in Najm et al., 2018 (doi: 10.1038/nbt.4048). All data was obtained from Supplementary Tables 2 and 3.

    library("gemini")
    data("counts", "guide.annotation", "sample.replicate.annotation", package = "gemini")

### Input

GEMINI takes a counts matrix as follows:

    knitr::kable(head(counts[,1:5]), caption = "Counts matrix", align = 'l')

Counts matrix
| pDNA | 786O.RepA | 786O.RepB | 786O.RepC | A375.RepA
--- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAAAAAAGAGTCGAATGTTTT | 1137 | 2438 | 1997 | 2175 | 1459
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAAGAGTCCACTCTGCACTTG | 1112 | 2176 | 1385 | 1485 | 1484
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AACAGCTCCGTGTACTGAGGC | 796 | 2294 | 1579 | 1844 | 1506
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAGACGAAATTGAAGACGAAG | 839 | 2169 | 1229 | 1705 | 1344
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAGCGTACTGCTCATCATCGT | 689 | 1771 | 984 | 1526 | 524
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;ACATTGCATACATAGAAGATC | 858 | 2833 | 1820 | 1866 | 1642

GEMINI also requires sample/replicate annotation and guide/gene annotation:

    knitr::kable(head(sample.replicate.annotation), caption = "Sample/replicate annotations")

Sample/replicate annotations
colname | samplename | replicate
--- | --- | ---
pDNA | pDNA | NA
786O.RepA | 786O | RepA
786O.RepB | 786O | RepB
786O.RepC | 786O | RepC
A375.RepA | A375 | RepA
A375.RepB | A375 | RepB

    knitr::kable(head(guide.annotation[,1:3]), caption = "Guide/gene annotation")

Guide/gene annotation
rowname | U6.gene | H1.gene
--- | --- | ---
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAAAAAAGAGTCGAATGTTTT | HPRT intron | 6T
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAAGAGTCCACTCTGCACTTG | HPRT intron | UBC
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AACAGCTCCGTGTACTGAGGC | HPRT intron | CD81
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAGACGAAATTGAAGACGAAG | HPRT intron | CD81
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;AAGCGTACTGCTCATCATCGT | HPRT intron | HSP90AA1
AAAGTGGAACTCAGGACATG;ACATTGCATACATAGAAGATC | HPRT intron | CHEK2

These can be used to create a `gemini.input` object using the `gemini_create_input` function.

    Input <- gemini_create_input(counts.matrix = counts,
                        sample.replicate.annotation = sample.replicate.annotation,
                        guide.annotation = guide.annotation,
                        ETP.column = 'pDNA',
                        gene.column.names = c("U6.gene", "H1.gene"),
                        sample.column.name = "samplename",
                        verbose = TRUE)

    ## Merging sample annotations with colnames of counts.matrix...

    ## Merging guide annotations with rownames()...

    ## Created gemini input object.

    # Note: ETP column can also be specified by column index
    # (e.g. ETP.column = c(1))

### Pre-processing

GEMINI requires log-fold changes as an input, which are calculated using the `gemini_calculate_lfc` function. A pseudo-count (`CONSTANT`) of \(32\) is used by default.

    Input %<>% gemini_calculate_lfc(normalize = TRUE,
                                    CONSTANT = 32)

### Initialization and Inference

To initialize the CAVI approach, a `gemini.model` object is created using the `gemini_initialize` function. For large libraries, more cores can be specified to speed up the initialization (see ?gemini_parallelization).

To note, it is highly recommended that at least one negative control gene should be specified here, and all other genes should be paired with at least one negative control. We use CD81 in this example.

In the absence of a negative control gene, the median LFC of all guide pairs targeting each gene is used to initialize the CAVI approach. However, this is only reasonable in all-by-all format screens.

Also to note, the `pattern_split` argument must describe a separator used in the rownames of the counts.matrix. For example, a semi-colon (“;”) is used in the Big Papi data and therefore specified here. On the other hand, `pattern_join` is specified by the user to join the gene pairs. For example, if the `U6.gene` is BRCA2, and the `H1.gene` is PARP1, the output will be “BRCA2{pattern_join}PARP1”.

    Model <- gemini_initialize(Input = Input,
                      nc_gene = "CD81",
                      pattern_join = ';',
                      pattern_split = ';',
                      cores = 1,
                      verbose = TRUE)

    ## Initializing x

    ## Initializing y

    ## Initializing s

    ## Initializing tau

    ## Updating mae

    ## Model initialized.

Inference is performed with the `gemini_inference` function. For large libraries, more cores can be specified to speed up the inference (see ?gemini_parallelization).

    Model %<>% gemini_inference(cores = 1,
                                verbose = FALSE)

### Convergence

After running `gemini_inference`, the resulting convergence rate can be visualized. If the model is divergent, alternative parameters for the priors should be selected until convergence is achieved. This can be done through cross-validation. Details on this will be added soon.

    gemini_plot_mae(Model)

### Scoring and Visualization

To score genetic interactions, use the `gemini_score` function.

To note, at least one positive control gene (`pc_gene`) should be specified to remove interactions involving individually lethal genes. If no positive control is explicitly specified, lethality is estimated as described in Zamanighomi et al. In short, the most lethal 1st percentile of individual gene effects is treated as the positive control value.

Additionally, non-interacting gene pairs (`nc_pairs`) should be specified for the calculation of p-values and false discovery rates (FDRs). If not specified, only scores are calculated, which reflects the relative strengths of interactions in each sample.

    # Use non-interacting gene pairs as nc_pairs.
    # A caveat here is that this set is constructed only using negative controls!
    # This probably leads to biased sampling of the null distribution,
    # thereby overestimating the number of significant hits, but still is useful in this case.
    nc_pairs <- grep("6T|HPRT", rownames(Model$s), value = TRUE)

    # An example of some nc_pairs...
    head(nc_pairs, n = 5)

    ## [1] "6T;HPRT intron"       "HPRT intron;UBC"      "HPRT intron;HSP90AA1"
    ## [4] "CHEK2;HPRT intron"    "AKT1;HPRT intron"

    Score <- gemini_score(Model = Model,
                 pc_gene = "EEF2",
                 nc_pairs = nc_pairs)

GEMINI’s scores for interactions can be seen in the Score object. Here, we show the top 10 interacting gene pairs in A549, with their scores across all cell lines.

    knitr::kable(Score$strong[order(Score$strong[,"A549"], decreasing = TRUE)[1:10],], caption = "Strong scores for top 10 interactions from A549 in all samples")

Strong scores for top 10 interactions from A549 in all samples
| 786O | A375 | A549 | HT29 | Meljuso | OVCAR8
--- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---
PARP1;WEE1 | 0.0453403 | 1.2379052 | 1.457047 | 0.3425539 | 0.4460586 | 0.2163869
MAPK1;MAPK3 | -0.0161569 | 0.7844598 | 1.382672 | 1.2829978 | 0.9680055 | 0.7177184
MAP2K1;PARP1 | 0.3458751 | 0.9409076 | 1.322750 | -0.2186067 | 0.1133638 | 0.0676618
BRCA2;PARP1 | 0.3805435 | 1.0314724 | 1.320199 | 0.2962005 | 0.5850402 | 0.5321259
AKT2;WEE1 | -0.1786742 | 0.4083603 | 1.272535 | 0.5039544 | 0.3303675 | -0.1330083
BRCA1;BRCA2 | 0.0733881 | 0.8185404 | 1.250131 | 0.6374952 | 0.9092236 | 0.4984216
BRCA2;WEE1 | -0.1443077 | 1.0850858 | 1.233050 | 0.6096170 | 0.8376799 | 0.0318263
BCL2L1;MCL1 | -1.4310350 | 1.1813920 | 1.156947 | -0.2542358 | 0.5450757 | 0.5775085
AKT2;BRCA2 | -0.1435939 | 0.1336293 | 1.141525 | 0.1821932 | 0.3429816 | -0.1009591
AKT2;PARP1 | 0.2634264 | 0.6327186 | 1.123986 | 0.2891668 | 0.2070908 | 0.0936534

Significant interactions can be identified through the FDR and p-value slots in the `Score` object. Again, we show the top 10 interacting gene pairs in A549, but now present FDRs across all cell lines.

    knitr::kable(Score$fdr_strong[order(Score$fdr_strong[,"A549"], decreasing = FALSE)[1:10],], caption = "FDRs for top 10 interactions in A549")

FDRs for top 10 interactions in A549
| 786O | A375 | A549 | HT29 | Meljuso | OVCAR8
--- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---
BRCA2;PARP1 | 0.3318827 | 0.0000590 | 8.10e-06 | 0.5034640 | 0.0132811 | 0.0310663
PARP1;WEE1 | 0.9995686 | 0.0000360 | 8.10e-06 | 0.3592092 | 0.0719586 | 0.4733378
MAP2K1;PARP1 | 0.4056094 | 0.0000746 | 8.10e-06 | 0.9959788 | 0.5728980 | 0.7975755
MAPK1;MAPK3 | 0.9995686 | 0.0002654 | 8.10e-06 | 0.0000156 | 0.0002616 | 0.0051505
AKT2;WEE1 | 0.9995686 | 0.0699194 | 1.03e-05 | 0.0649227 | 0.2031566 | 0.9547407
BRCA1;BRCA2 | 0.9995146 | 0.0001786 | 1.07e-05 | 0.0115084 | 0.0002616 | 0.0482600
BRCA2;WEE1 | 0.9995686 | 0.0000587 | 1.08e-05 | 0.0165822 | 0.0002846 | 0.8451784
BCL2L1;MCL1 | 0.9995686 | 0.0000382 | 1.92e-05 | 0.9959788 | 0.0246745 | 0.0174912
AKT2;BRCA2 | 0.9995686 | 0.4545398 | 1.96e-05 | 0.8869871 | 0.1809226 | 0.9546188
AKT2;PARP1 | 0.6929921 | 0.0028113 | 2.07e-05 | 0.5223458 | 0.3815660 | 0.7572944

To visualize these interactions, we can use the `gemini_boxplot` function. For example, in BRCA2-PARP1:

    gemini_boxplot(Model = Model,
                   g = "BRCA2",
                   h = "PARP1",
                   nc_gene = "CD81",
                   sample = "A549",
                   show_inference = TRUE,
                   identify_guides = TRUE
                   )

We can see that GEMINI makes adjustments to the individual gene effects of both BRCA2 and PARP1, and adjusts the sample-independent values of each to account for variation in the screen.

This boxplot can also be re-colored by the adjustment made to each guide or guide pair through the sample-independent effects. Guides/guide pairs with the least adjustment to x (grey) are considered to have the least variation within the screen.

    gemini_boxplot(Model = Model,
                   g = "BRCA2",
                   h = "PARP1",
                   nc_gene = "CD81",
                   sample = "A549",
                   show_inference = TRUE,
                   color_x = TRUE
                   )

### Summary

GEMINI can be run on any counts matrix from a pairwise screen. GEMINI computes log fold changes and infers sample-dependent and sample-independent effects using CAVI. Then, GEMINI calculates interaction strength and significance.

The manuscript and more visualization tools will be made available soon.

### Session Info

    sessionInfo()

    ## R version 4.2.0 RC (2022-04-19 r82224 ucrt)
    ## Platform: x86_64-w64-mingw32/x64 (64-bit)
    ## Running under: Windows Server x64 (build 20348)
    ##
    ## Matrix products: default
    ##
    ## locale:
    ## [1] LC_COLLATE=C
    ## [2] LC_CTYPE=English_United States.utf8
    ## [3] LC_MONETARY=English_United States.utf8
    ## [4] LC_NUMERIC=C
    ## [5] LC_TIME=English_United States.utf8
    ##
    ## attached base packages:
    ## [1] stats     graphics  grDevices utils     datasets  methods   base
    ##
    ## other attached packages:
    ## [1] gemini_1.10.0
    ##
    ## loaded via a namespace (and not attached):
    ##  [1] mixtools_1.2.0   tidyselect_1.1.2 xfun_0.30        bslib_0.3.1
    ##  [5] purrr_0.3.4      kernlab_0.9-30   splines_4.2.0    lattice_0.20-45
    ##  [9] colorspace_2.0-3 vctrs_0.4.1      generics_0.1.2   htmltools_0.5.2
    ## [13] yaml_2.3.5       utf8_1.2.2       survival_3.3-1   rlang_1.0.2
    ## [17] jquerylib_0.1.4  pillar_1.7.0     withr_2.5.0      glue_1.6.2
    ## [21] DBI_1.1.2        segmented_1.5-0  lifecycle_1.0.1  stringr_1.4.0
    ## [25] munsell_0.5.0    gtable_0.3.0     evaluate_0.15    labeling_0.4.2
    ## [29] knitr_1.38       fastmap_1.1.0    parallel_4.2.0   fansi_1.0.3
    ## [33] pbmcapply_1.5.0  highr_0.9        scales_1.2.0     jsonlite_1.8.0
    ## [37] farver_2.1.0     ggplot2_3.3.5    digest_0.6.29    stringi_1.7.6
    ## [41] dplyr_1.0.8      grid_4.2.0       cli_3.3.0        tools_4.2.0
    ## [45] magrittr_2.0.3   sass_0.4.1       tibble_3.1.6     crayon_1.5.1
    ## [49] pkgconfig_2.0.3  ellipsis_0.3.2   MASS_7.3-57      Matrix_1.4-1
    ## [53] assertthat_0.2.1 rmarkdown_2.14   R6_2.5.1         compiler_4.2.0